Independent healthcare research guidesPatient & Consumer Engagement

Developing a Measure of Health Insurance Literacy: Concepts and Consumer Skills

Stethoscope placed on a stack of health-related paperwork

When health coverage choices become complex, researchers need ways to distinguish knowing insurance terminology from being able to use a policy. AIR’s February 2013 issue brief described why a health insurance literacy measure was needed and how consumer challenges informed its development. This educational guide explains the underlying concepts and practical uses without reproducing the original report.

Why measure health insurance literacy at all?

Health insurance combines unfamiliar language, multiple plan structures, financial trade-offs, and deadlines. Consumers may be expected to choose among options before they have used coverage or received a medical bill. Without a reliable measure, organizations may mistake a complicated form for a consumer knowledge problem—or assume that a short set of definitions will solve deeper reasoning and navigation difficulties. AIR proposed assessing how people find, evaluate, select, and use coverage.

The scope of the February 2013 AIR brief

The report, titled Developing a Measure of Health Insurance Literacy: Understanding Consumers’ Ability to Choose and Use Insurance, discussed interviews with health insurance counselors and other stakeholders. The aim was to identify common difficulties and outline a strategy for creating an assessment that could guide outreach, plan comparisons, and consumer communication. The brief predates later measurement and validation work, so its development-stage claims should not be confused with findings from subsequent surveys.

Knowledge: terms, concepts, and consumer rights

Knowledge items address concepts such as premium, deductible, network, covered services, appeals, and the difference between plan structures. The objective is not to reward memorization of jargon. A good item asks whether respondents can apply a concept in circumstances resembling a decision they may face. Knowledge questions should use unambiguous language and avoid assuming that all participants have identical insurance experience.

Information seeking: knowing where and what to ask

A person may need to identify reliable materials, compare sources, verify an in-network provider, or ask questions before choosing coverage. Information-seeking skills include recognizing when a document is incomplete and knowing which organization can clarify a rule. Researchers can test these abilities through short scenarios rather than only asking whether participants believe they would know where to look.

Document literacy: extracting meaning from plan materials

Insurance documents often contain tables, exclusions, small print, and terms that interact with one another. Reading skill is relevant, but insurance-specific document literacy also includes recognizing which benefit statement applies to a scenario and identifying what information is missing. Clearer standardized benefit summaries may help, yet documents still require usability testing with representative consumers.

Numeracy and reasoning: making the information usable

Comparing two plans may require estimating total premium contributions, likely service use, cost sharing, and financial risk. Even a correct definition of coinsurance will not solve every calculation. A practical measurement tool can use realistic problems, clear answer choices, and cognitive interviewing to see whether respondents interpret questions as intended. The choice of examples matters because complex tasks can otherwise measure irrelevant reading burden.

What organizations can learn from the measure

Health exchanges, benefit counselors, employers, insurers, and advocates can use insights about literacy gaps to improve explanations and prioritize assistance. A measure is useful when it identifies actionable barriers rather than simply assigning a label to a person. Findings should be interpreted with attention to sample characteristics, language access, disability access, and differences in previous exposure to the insurance system.

Connecting the development work to later research

AIR later developed and validated the Health Insurance Literacy Measure (HILM). Later AIR reports examined the gap between confidence and performance in working through health insurance decisions. This page provides background on the earlier development phase; readers can use the linked project materials to follow how the research program evolved and to distinguish the stages of evidence.

The AIRCPCE homepage connects this measurement background with other explanations of insurance literacy and patient-centered research.

References and further reading